Laws of the Night: Banishment versus Anima Gathering

QUESTION: Vampire A plays Banishment on vampire B, who has Anima Gathering. Does Anima Gathering disappear when vampire B is brought out of the uncontrolled area again?

ANSWER: No. Vampire B enters the uncontrolled area untapped, but it´s controller has never chosen not to untap it (as per the card text), so the Gathering sticks. (LSJ 20060213. Note that LSJ has confessed to making an incorrect ruling about this 20060811.)